If you’ve recently filed an auto insurance claim, you’re likely wondering, “How much will my rates go up?” The answer isn’t always straightforward—auto insurance premiums can surge after a claim, but the exact amount depends on several factors. Understanding these details can help you prepare for changes to your auto insurance and make informed decisions about your coverage. In this guide, we’ll break down the key factors that influence post-claim rate increases, provide real-world data, and offer tips to help you manage your auto insurance costs.
When you file an auto insurance claim—especially after an at-fault accident—your insurer will reassess your risk profile. Insurance companies use complex algorithms to determine how much to raise your rates, considering factors like your driving history, the severity of the accident, and even your location. While not every claim leads to a rate hike, most drivers see an increase after an at-fault incident.
Recent data reveals that auto insurance premiums can jump significantly after a claim:
Average Increase: After an at-fault accident, premiums typically rise by an average of 58%—but this varies widely by state and insurer.
State Variations: For example, New Jersey drivers see an average increase of 80%, while Rhode Island residents may only experience a 15% bump.
Insurer Differences: Some insurers, like Geico, have been found to increase rates by as much as 82% after an at-fault accident, while others, such as State Farm, average a 23% increase.
Other Factors: If you have a history of accidents or traffic violations, your rate increase could be even higher.
Insurance companies raise rates after a claim for several reasons:
Increased Risk: Statistically, drivers who file claims are more likely to file again in the future.
Loss of Discounts: Many insurers offer a “no claims bonus” or similar discount for claim-free years. Filing a claim can cause you to lose this discount, resulting in a higher premium.
Claim Severity: The more severe the accident or the higher the payout, the more likely your rates will rise.
Most insurers will keep your higher premium in place for three to five years after an at-fault accident, depending on your driving record and state regulations. After this period, assuming you remain claim-free, your rates may decrease.
Ask About Accident Forgiveness: Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs, which can prevent your rates from increasing after your first at-fault accident—though this usually comes at an additional cost.
Take a Defensive Driving Course: Completing a defensive driving course can sometimes qualify you for a discount and help mitigate a rate increase.
Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Avoiding further accidents and violations is the best way to reduce your rates over time.
Filing an auto insurance claim can lead to a significant increase in your premiums, especially if you were at fault. However, the exact amount depends on your insurer, your state, and your driving history. By understanding these factors and exploring options like accident forgiveness or defensive driving courses, you can better manage your auto insurance costs after a claim.
At Scavone Insurance Agency Center LLC, we’re here to help you navigate the complexities of auto insurance and find the best coverage for your needs. Contact us today to learn more about your options and how to protect yourself on the road. You can also call us directly at (914) 428-7111.
Understanding your rights and options after a claim is important. Here are some helpful government resources:
New York State Department of Financial Services: Offers consumer guides and information about auto insurance regulations and rate increases. Visit the NYSDFS website
National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC): Provides state-specific information and resources on auto insurance claims and rate changes. Visit the NAIC website
Federal Trade Commission (FTC): Offers tips on shopping for auto insurance and understanding your rights as a consumer. Visit the FTC website
Below are four common questions about auto insurance rate increases after a claim that is not directly answered in the blog above.
Generally, only claims that indicate increased risk—such as at-fault accidents—cause significant rate increases. Comprehensive claims (like theft or weather damage) may have less impact, but this varies by insurer and claim frequency.
Some insurers may not raise your rates after a not-at-fault accident, but others could still adjust your premium based on claim history and other factors. Always check with your provider.
While you can’t always negotiate the increase, you can discuss your options, such as accident forgiveness or discounts for defensive driving courses, with your agent.
Minor claims may result in smaller rate increases or none at all, depending on your insurer and policy. Major accidents, especially those with injuries or significant damage, are more likely to cause substantial rate hikes.
Get a Customized Quote and Additional Information From Us on How Our Insurance Products Can
Meet Your Personal and Commercial Needs.
